On July 15, Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker, along with several other members of the Illinois General Assembly, gathered with exonerated individuals, as well as attorneys with the Bluhm Legal ...
Christmas came two weeks early for Raymond McCann II when St. Joseph County, Michigan Circuit Court Judge Paul E. Stutesman signed an order today granting McCann’s motion to vacate his 2012 perjury conviction. The motion was filed by the Center on Wrongful Convictions at Northwestern Law and the Michigan Innocence Clinic at the University of Michigan Law School and was joined by St. Joseph County Prosecutor John McDonough who stipulated that the motion should be granted and the charges dropped. “We are grateful to John McDonough,” said Gregory Swygert, the lead attorney from the Center on Wrongful Convictions team. “Today, he acted honorably in placing his duty to seek justice ahead of his desire to preserve a wrongful conviction.”
McCann’s exoneration marks the end of a nightmare that began on November 8, 2007, when 11-year-old Jodi Parrack was reported missing in the small town of Constantine, Michigan. McCann, a reserve police officer, agreed to help participate in the search. He became a “person of interest” in the case after he was one of several people to suggest searching the local cemetery. Parrack’s body was found there a short time later. Police continued to pursue McCann aggressively for years even though DNA evidence found on the victim did not match McCann.
Constantine police officers and detectives from a Michigan State Police task force questioned McCann nearly two dozen times over nearly five years after Parrack’s body was discovered. A Michigan State Police detective falsely told McCann they had evidence tying him to the murder—including that McCann’s DNA was on Parrack’s body and Parrack’s DNA was in McCann’s truck. The detective also told lies about McCann to his family members and friends, even telling McCann’s teenage son that McCann was a drug addict, in an apparent attempt to turn his family and friends against him and get McCann to confess. Despite intense pressure, McCann insisted that he was innocent. “Although the tactics failed to coerce Ray into making a false confession,” said Swygert, “the tactics did succeed at ruining his reputation and destroying his relationships with family and friends. He lost his job, was estranged from his son, and his wife divorced him.”
In 2012, with the investigation going cold, the Michigan State Police detective told one of McCann’s relatives that he wanted to see McCann locked up to increase the pressure on him to confess. The detective then persuaded the county prosecutor to issue a subpoena to require McCann to testify under oath concerning his whereabouts at the time of Parrack’s disappearance. In 2014, the prosecutor then charged McCann with perjury during a murder investigation, which carries a life sentence. All of the charges stemmed from minor discrepancies between McCann’s recall of the events surrounding Parrack’s disappearance five years earlier and the recollections of others.
One of the perjury counts stemmed from McCann’s testimony that he had searched for Parrack at the Tumble Dam, a ruin where Constantine kids often hung out. McCann said under oath that he had parked at the trailhead and was prepared to search for Parrack there when he got a call and went elsewhere. The Michigan State Police detective testified under oath that video footage from a surveillance camera on a nearby factory proved McCann was never there that night.
After spending 11 months in jail awaiting trial and facing a potential life sentence, McCann pled no contest to the count involving the Tumble Dam, believing that he had no chance of being acquitted if there was a video that contradicted his recollection, especially in a community that was convinced he had murdered Jodi Parrack. He was sentenced to 20 months in prison in 2015.
While McCann was in prison, a man named Daniel Furlong attempted to abduct another young girl in nearby White Pigeon, Michigan. The girl got away and led authorities back to Daniel Furlong. Furlong, who lived in Constantine at the time of Parrack’s murder, eventually admitted to killing Parrack eight years earlier, and a subsequent DNA test on Furlong matched that found on Parrack. Under interrogation, Furlong insisted he did not know McCann and told the authorities that when he learned that McCann had been arrested, he believed that “he was in the clear.”
After McCann was paroled from prison, Ken Kolker, a television reporter from WOODTV in Grand Rapids, contacted Steven Drizin, an attorney at Northwestern’s Center on Wrongful Convictions, and asked him to evaluate the interrogations of McCann. “This was one of the worst cases of police tunnelvision I’ve ever seen,” said Drizin. “The detectives were so desperate to solve this case and so blinded by their belief that McCann must have been involved, that they ignored powerful evidence pointing to his innocence.” In fact, even after Furlong was identified by DNA evidence as the killer, the authorities went to McCann’s prison and tried to pressure him into admitting that he and Furlong were accomplices. Again, McCann refused to falsely confess to knowing Furlong. “This case highlights the dangers of how strong tunnel can be. Here the tunnel vision had such momentum that even after DNA and Furlong’s confession completely exonerating Ray, it still took years and the force of two law school legal clinics to finally have his conviction vacated,” Swygert said.
Drizin recruited his colleagues Greg Swygert and Megan Crane from the Center on Wrongful Convictions, and students Courtney Cronin and Caroline McMahon, to work on the case and approached David Moran, the Director of the Michigan Innocence Clinic, to see if he was interested in partnering. In March of 2016, Moran agreed and lawyers and students from both projects launched a re-investigation in the case.
“The big break in the case came as a result of brilliant work on the part of the Michigan Law students,” said Swygert. The Michigan students made two important discoveries which proved that there was no video evidence to prove that McCann had lied under oath about driving to the Tumble Dam. First, the students established that darkness made it impossible to tell whether McCann’s car or any other specific cars were in the area near the Tumble Dam path. Second, further investigation and a closer look at the video revealed that video camera could not have captured McCann’s car because the cameras were not facing the direction of the path to the Tumble Dam. These discoveries made it clear that the Michigan State Police detective, who had accused McCann of lying, had testified falsely about the video to Prosecutor McDonough.
While elated that his legal nightmare is finally over, McCann is still trying to put the pieces of his life back together. He hopes to work to change the law that led to his wrongful conviction. “The perjury statute that coerced Ray to plead guilty needs to be changed. The threat of a life sentence for what could simply be differing recollections is too strong a tool for prosecutors and could lead to further wrongful convictions. Even Judge Stutesman, who accepted the plea and sentenced Ray has said the law as terrible,” said Swygert.
Mr. McCann’s case marks the Center on Wrongful Convictions’ third partnership with the Michigan Innocence Clinic, all of which have resulted in exonerations. The other exonerated clients include Jamie Peterson (Kalkaska County) and Davontae Sanford (Wayne County).
For more background information about the case, see Ken Kolker’s “Making a Monster” on WOODTV.
Vanessa del Valle, clinical assistant professor of law at the MacArthur Justice Center at the Bluhm Legal Clinic, has been appointed by Governor J.B. Pritzker to the State of Illinois Torture ...
“A Critical Moment:” Clinic Attorneys Lend Their Expertise to Chicago Organizers as Protests Continue
In addition to their ongoing work related to the COVID-19 pandemic, attorneys at the Bluhm Legal Clinic have been engaged in Chicago’s protests of the racial injustice and police brutality ...